A Student Minister’s Response to 13 Reasons Why

2017-05-02 10.51.38.pngGuest Post by Tyler Goudeau:

You need to know about the Netflix series 13 Reasons Why. It was released on March 31st of this year. You need to know about this series as a parent or as a citizen. At this point, if your students are anything like the ones I work with about half of the high school students I talked to have finished this 13-part series.

Ever since the invention of television it seems like each generation has a movie that helps identify that era. Movies like Grease, 16 Candles, Mean Girls, and others,  help define a generation. It’s possible that 13 Reasons Why will become that movie for this generation. It is distributed on the media platform, Netflix, that this generation has grown up with. It fits the binge watching style we crave and however scary it might be it depicts this generation more accurately than any other media I have seen.

The series is well produced with great acting, writing, video production, and everything else you would expect out of a big Hollywood budget. Its received reviews from critics and is quickly turning into the latest drama series fad.

So what’s the big deal? 13 Reasons Why is a fictional series centered around the suicide of a teenage girl, Hannah Baker.  She records 13 cassette tapes explaining why she made her decision based on 13 people who’ve hurt her.  The series is seen through the eyes of Clay Jensen, a nerdy boy who has always had a crush on Hannah Baker. It follows him along as he puts the pieces of Hannah’s suicide together while dealing with grief and getting some retribution along the way.

The series vividly depicts scenes of: sexual assault, sexting, bullying, multiple rape scenes, parental neglect, oral sex, drug and alcohol abuse, depression, stalkings, profanity, masturbation, school shootings, and a suicide with nothing left to the imagination. 

All of this is shocking. You may need a second to let it sink in. A concern is that this series will glorify or romanticize suicide. Another issue is that we may not want to acknowledge how painfully accurate many of these issues are in the lives of our students. Many times the series shows students going through incredibly difficult problems with adults and parents present, yet unaware.

Some events were so similar to events at my high school that I turned it off to research if the writer of the book, Jay Asher, went to high school with me. Whether we like it or not and no matter how much we try to protect them, these are issues our students are facing.  I want you to be informed as you make decisions about how you and your family will approach this series. More importantly, I hope that you will have some difficult conversations with the students in your life about the issues portrayed in this series. I hope that you will be active in the lives of the students you are connected to and that they can trust you enough to approach you if these issues were part of their life.

This series gives 13 reasons why a teenage girl, Hannah Baker, killed herself. It is possible that many could list their own 13 reasons why. Life can be tragic and can be seen as hopeless. Instead, I see 13 reasons why grace is profoundly relevant. Forgiveness is needed 13 times 7 in this Netflix series.  More than that, actually. More like 70 times 7 as one wise man once said. The Great Healer never mentioned or seen in this series is eagerly waiting to restore all wounds.

Many counselors, psychologists, and suicide experts are weighing in on concerns about the series (see links below). You can find countless articles that professionals have posted talking about the series. From the perspective of a student minister who works daily with middle school and high school students the thing that concerns me the most is how deeply secular the series portrays life.  The characters lack good coping skills to deal with the difficult trials of life. They are often hopeless, selfish, and have no belief that they can change.

In the midst of all this I have good news! Times might be different and new technology can bring new challenges. This generation may be unique but they share similarities with all the generations before them. It has its strengths and weaknesses. However, the good news is still the same. Grace, forgiveness, and redemption through Jesus Christ is still the answer to this generation’s problems. Praise God that we get to offer real hope to this generation!

You’re invited to learn more about the series and how to deal with suicide at Life Lessons on Sunday, May 14th from 5:30 to 7:30 pm at the Littleton Church of Christ. Dr. Ryan Hall (PhD in Suicideology) will be leading a discussion entitled 13 Reasons to Talk about Suicide.  If you are a parent of a teenager come and bring them with you. Please come and bring a friend. 


What do you think of Thirteen Reasons Why? Please respond with your comments below.

Tyler Goudeau is the Student Minister at the Littleton Church of Christ in Denver, Colorado. You can follow Tyler on Twitter @tylergoudeau



2 thoughts on “A Student Minister’s Response to 13 Reasons Why

  1. Hi, Jovan, We’ve never met yet but my wife, Lois Elliott, and I attended the Littleton C of C for 45 years until 2013. I’d like to tell you about a real miracle that happened to us. My wife has negative blood but I and all 3 of our kiddos have positive blood. Our second kid (a girl) had to have her blood changed out twice in the first 24 hours after birth because of the RH negative factor in her blood. However, our next kiddo was also another girl and she had serious complications before birth. She had to be taken early when she weighed only 4 lbs. because of major problems. She had already undergone 3 intrauterine transfusions at the CU Med Center in Denver before birth. Within the first few weeks, while she was still at CU, her stomach began swelling up and by the 6th week, it was at least 3 times its normal size. The head of the Premie Nursery called us in at that point and advised us that the doctors there had given up on her and they asked us to sign papers to allow them to experiment on her before she died. We told him that we hadn’t given up on her and refused to sign. We immediately called the Littleton minister and asked for the prayers of the church (his daughters had done some bay sitting for us and we really admired them for the good job they did. They would leave sweet little notes for us to read to our kids after they went home).

    The next morning, one of the Premie doctors came back smiling as he carried our sweet little angel back in from running a test on her at another hospital. He said that the test showed that there was still hope because her liver was badly damaged but still functioning. It turned out that he had just that morning received the results of a culture test that takes 6 weeks to run. It told them that she has CID Hepatitis from one of the intrauterine transfusions. He said that 90% of an infant’s liver can cease functioning but that the remaining 10% has been known to restore it back to normal. THIS WAS THE BEGINNING OF A MIRACULOUS RECOVERY THAT RESULTED IN HER RETURNING TO A FULLY HEALTHY CONDITION!!!!! In fact, for the last 45 years, she has been the healthiest one in our family!

    For the next year however, she was in such a delicate condition that either my wife or I had to stay with her at all times. She had been trained to sleep on her back and she still weighed only 4 !/2 lbs. when we took her home at 2 months old. Her passage ways were so tiny that she would choke from time to time and we had to turn her over and pat her back so she could breath again. She was about 4 months old before we could take her out to church because she would catch a cold or flu from our own kids regularly. During her first winter beginning at 8 months, she was sick all winter long and had to be kept from all outsiders. Even as she started her second winter, she started getting sick again and, in desperation, I finally found a brand of Vitamin C that she could tolerate and she healed up and stayed healthy all winter long. Finally!

    It turned out that the CU Med Center was the pioneer for intrauterine transfusions and one of her 2 specialists went on to become famous regarding this procedure. The Denver Belle Bonfils blood bank was directed to change the procedures for all future RH negative blood baby transfusions. From then on, world wide, the mother’s own blood would be drawn and stored in advance for use for the intrauterine transfusions.

    For good reason, we call our little angel our MIRACLE GIRL! Her doctors wrote a paper about her recovery and a government grant allowed them to monitor her situation for several years. She always amazed those doctors when she came in for follow up visits. Since she had stopped breathing 3 different times the day of her birth, the doctors told us that she may have suffered some brain damage. However, that wasn’t a problem because when she was 4 years old, her paternal grandparents’ phone rang one day. My Dad answered it and it was our girl Tanya, who had never been taught to use a phone but she had memorized their phone number a week earlier while visiting them and, by watching us dial a phone, she had taught herself how to do it. We were all flabbergasted!

    No one can tell us that the age of miracles is past!!!!!!

    PS.We now live in the Dallas area where we have several younger grandkids.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s